“Putting the ‘we’ in WISA: A radical notion in student affairs” By Susan Marine

The forwards came pouring in to my inbox this week, and I found myself both amused and amazed at the number of colleagues who thought of me before hitting ‘send.’ The topic of the moment was a blog post authored by Eric Stoller on Inside Higher Ed entitled “where are the radical practitioners?” In this post, Stoller asked several important questions about whether the field of higher education student affairs supports and nurtures self-identified radicals, or whether in fact the norms of our profession serve to isolate them (us). As all my kind colleagues who forwarded the post intuited, Stoller’s most provocative query rang true to what I’ve spent a great deal of time and energy trying to discern: does student affairs deconstruct the status quo, or do we sustain it?

 

I’ve been interested in radicalism in our profession for a long time, ever since I took my first job as a sexual assault educator and found myself regularly lots of questions beginning with the word ‘why.’ By radicalism, I do not mean simply having a penchant for organizing, picketing, or defying authority for the sake of doing so.  Instead, I mean the kind of radicalism – the Latin root of the word, after all, is root — typified by asking difficult but important questions about the root causes of inequality in higher education, a willingness to engage in analysis of the power structures that operate in higher education, and a commitment to doing so in the service of determining where we can be most impactful in paving the way for greater participation of ‘the many’ in all that higher education has to offer. When I began my doctoral work fifteen years later, everything I read about the founders of our profession, and their ingenuity and vision in arguing for education of the whole student, suggested that the legacy of our work is, inherently, change. As each year passes, I am more convinced that the value of the work we do will not really be about our ability to translate the work we do in terms of quantifiable learning outcomes. It will be ultimately determined by whether and how we have managed to swing the proverbial doors open more widely, and in turn, change the very way we think about what it means to participate in a college education.

 

I care very much about this question, and if you’re reading this, I suspect you do, too.

 

This community is about promoting women in student affairs, and I would guess that most of us are sympathetic to (if not self identified with) the aims of feminism. Together with my colleagues Pat Fabiano and Marlene Kowalski-Braun, I helped to facilitate a conversation at the 2009 NASPA conference in Seattle about feminist leadership in student affairs. What started as a desire to have meaningful, if modest, conversation about what it means to commit to acting radically in everyday ways became a heartening demonstration of solidarity. To our great surprise, the room was packed. We learned from this experience that feminists were everywhere in higher education student affairs. We were working, carefully and thoughtfully, to change higher education from the inside. We were working to enact an environment that focused on empowering those who were typically not at the table, and to make their voices and needs more visible on campus. We were doing so without a guidebook, and frequently, with only each other and our ability to witness each other’s bravery as a template. And while many spoke of the difficulties encountered in doing so, no one spoke of wanting to detach from the effort. The stakes of not acting in feminist ways, and the rewards of doing so, are simply too great.

 

What came as less of a surprise to us than the number of participants in the room was the vivid reminder being together is the first step to moving forward. We can effect change, and make the kind of difference we care about, but are far more powerful when we do so together. The isolation experienced when we feel disconnected from others like us is a powerful deterrent to acting radically. When we can’t see ourselves, or our values, in the actions of others, not only is transformation less palpable, but the sheer joy of participating in social change is dampened.

 

That’s what makes participation in communities like this one so important. You may not think of yourself as a radical, and that’s okay. By my definition, being radical – being committed to a sense of fairness, equality, and actively resisting the status quo  in everyday ways – is not an easy path, in student affairs or in any other profession. The fact is that the norms and cultural values that govern higher education do not easily abide change. But in creation of networks to link those who are committed to this vision to one another, we strengthen the fabric of the enterprise for everyone. We make a different vision part of the conversation. We find it in ourselves to keep going. WE, ultimately, make WISA what it is. But if we decide to step away, the fabric is frayed. That’s why we must endeavor above all to listen and understand each other, through the noise of daily life, political expediency, and career advancement. I’m convinced there really isn’t any other way.

 

Though I’m glad to be thought of, in some small way, as a radical in student affairs, I know in my heart that what I value about higher education isn’t really radical at all. It’s simply, as Martin Luther King, Jr. said, the arc of the moral universe, bending towards justice. And so I bring the question back to you – are you a radical? Can you muster support for others who are? Can we find ways to be both radical, and thoughtful, and patient? What does a true commitment to equity ask of us, and how do we know where we can make the most difference? Most importantly, how can we support each other in doing it, and continue to love our work? That may be the most radical act of all.

 

Susan Marine is an Assistant Professor of Higher Education at Merrimack College.

 

 

 

Advertisements

10 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

10 responses to ““Putting the ‘we’ in WISA: A radical notion in student affairs” By Susan Marine

  1. Thank you, Susan for this very thoughtful blog. You hit the nail on the head with your question – “Can we find ways to be both radical, and thoughtful, and patient?” By its very nature, change can be fraught with conflict and turmoil. The status quo won’t be transformed quietly – it will go down kicking and screaming. The best leaders recognize this reality and take the time to develop positive, supportive relationships to lessen the stress of change. They also recognize that the conflict that occurs during change can be beneficial to the process, if responded to constructively.

    Thanks again for getting my brain working this morning!!

    • Susan Marine

      Thanks Cathy! you couldn’t be more right-on with your observation that the status quo will go down kicking and screaming. Coming to terms with that reality requires shrewdness, strategy, and making sure that we have friends who can listen and help us think through our approaches. This is what the best mentors do, I think– in fact, I’d like to propose we redefine mentoring as ‘survival skills for budding radicals’ 🙂 thanks for your thoughts and insights.

  2. KinZ6

    Great points in this post. I appreciate your connecting radicalism in student affairs to feminism in student affairs. ‘Being together is the first step towards moving forward,’ is so, so true for women in our profession. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. –Amy P.

    • Susan Marine

      Thanks for your affirming reply, Amy! I hope you feel equally supported in your efforts to both be supported, and move things forward. Know that I am in your corner, even if we’ve never met 🙂

  3. Tamar Frolichstein-Appel

    Any tips for fighting the status quo in the hierarchical world that is higher education?

    • Tamar:

      You asked the million dollar question. My .50 cent answer is develop relationships that are more powerful than the hierarchy. Find the courage to communicate what you believe and you will attract others who believe what you believe. You are then in a position to challenge the “system” due to the energy generated by your connections. As a word of caution, the stronger the “system” is challenged, the stronger it fights back to maintain itself – the rubber band effect. So, if you and your allies are willing to look for common ground with the “system” and make positive, but incremental changes, before you know it progress has been made with minimum disruption.

      Cathy

    • Susan Marine

      Hi Tamar,
      The challenge for all of us, I think, is to have a relationship with our work for change that doesn’t always require us to be oppositional. In other words, can we work from any other paradigm than, “I’m not going to give up, and if you don’t either, I’ll outlast you.” WHile I don’t buy in to essentialist theories about women that say we’re the ‘kinder; gentler gender,’ I do think we can learn so much from emulating the strategies of peaeful change agents (of all genders). if we are only ever ‘fighting,’ and never ‘engaging in dialogue,’ we will become one-dimensional radicals.

  4. Robin

    Can’t say enough about how much I appreciate your post!

  5. Jill Stratton

    Susan—thank you for your thoughtful, challenging post. There is indeed joy in transforming and participating in social change, and it is much more effective, rewarding, and powerful when we do it together.

    Thank you for asking powerful questions. As many wise people (including you) remind us–while the answers to these questions are not easy and may never be fully answered, it is in the process of asking of the questions that the transformation takes place and social change deepens.

    p.s. So glad I was your RA many years ago at Transylvania University. I learn so much from you. Now–YOU are my RA!

  6. Susan Marine

    Dear Jill,
    I couldn’t agree more! and am always glad that you still love me even with all the crap I pulled back in 88-89. Now that I am a radical, I am wayyyy more responsible 😉
    hugs,
    Susan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s